Validity and Power of Heavy-Tailed Combination Tests under Asymptotic Dependence

Abstract

Heavy-tailed combination tests, such as the Cauchy combination test and harmonic mean p-value method, are widely used for testing global null hypotheses by aggregating dependent p-values. However, their theoretical guarantees under general dependence structures remain limited. We develop a unified framework using multivariate regularly varying copulas to model the joint behavior of p-values near zero. Within this framework, we show that combination tests remain asymptotically valid when the transformation distribution has a tail index γ≤1, with γ=1 maximizing power while preserving validity. The Bonferroni test emerges as a limiting case when γ→0 and becomes overly conservative under asymptotic dependence. Consequently, combination tests with γ=1 achieve increasing asymptotic power gains over Bonferroni as p-values exhibit stronger lower-tail dependence and signals are not extremely sparse. Our results provide theoretical support for using truncated Cauchy or Pareto combination tests, offering a principled approach to enhance power while controlling false positives under complex dependence.

Publication
The Annals of Statistics, accepted
Lin Gui
Lin Gui
PhD alum, 2026
Jingshu Wang
Jingshu Wang
Assistant Professor in Statistics